I have read about Nosara that it is a community with a specific lifestyle and commitment to that view. I have also heard it said that Nosara is not for everybody. Before coming I wondered what that could mean when everything sounded so appealing. I may be getting my answer through the school community.
Today we had a guided tour of the local super market by the school nutritionist. The school food health program is by far the most strict I’ve ever seen. My children have never eaten fast food and we cook fresh and natural more often than not. The school’s healthy snack and lunch parameters are even sending me with questions.
Today’s tour was a good example of some other curiosities I’ve had about this community. In maneuvering down the isles, the nutritionist pointed out largely imported food as best for your health.
The past few weeks I have struggled with the high price of goods in this area or simply the lack of basic items (like a laundry drying rack.) In a (broken Spanish) talk with my house helper (more about her later because she is a dream) even she makes regular trips to Nicoya, a 1-2 hour bus ride away, for goods.
Nosara is truly isolated in how far it is from infrastructure and how challenging it is to navigate these unpredictable and unpaved roads. Westerners profess coming here for the pure life, the simpler life, a life less materialistic. But I see materialism here in a different context. Life here is also complicated and just as expensive as living in North America.
For all of the values of healthy diet, they compromise a huge carbon footprint just to get goods (like soy and rice milk) here.
For all of the support for the environment, they need beastly vehicles to navigate these “rustic” roads.
If you are eating well or navigating these roads by vehicle, you are utilizing resources that are not totally necessary. To do this, you are spending a lot of money. If you need a lot of money, you are not living simply.
When the price of simplicity is so high, you have gone off course.
I see here that when we choose a life of extreme purity we are doomed to contradiction in some adjacent area.
I hear the standards here but I aim for somewhere in the middle, even if it means that I won’t fit in completely.
And then... I compare this with other places I have lived. I consider my concerns with schools and North American culture. I reflect on the values my kids were around and how I worried about their exposure to materialism, junk food, inappropriate television, etc. It is just the opposite extreme. When I ask myself where I would rather be, I choose here! - even with all of the extremes and their contradictions.
Now, I see the contradictions as a way these residents have of making this place of beauty work for them with some of the comforts of home and priority to values that come from another place. Then it seems like the compromises they make for a better life and their demands don't seem so extreme anymore. It also makes the residents seem more real and less ideal.
How ironic that it is our contradictions that make us balanced.